Investment Strategy2025-11-11
Dividend Aristocrat ETFs Prove Defensive Strength Amid Market Volatility
Dividend growth ETFs such as SCHD and VIG have outperformed the S&P 500 during the recent market correction. Interest is growing among retirees and investors seeking stable cash flow.
AdminCNBC
During the mid-October market correction, the S&P 500 fell 5.2% while SCHD declined only 2.8% and VIG dropped 3.1%, demonstrating solid defensive qualities. Dividend aristocrats with 25 or more consecutive years of dividend increases have been serving as safe-haven assets in downturns, supported by strong cash flows and attractive valuations. Adding a dividend growth rate of 7–10% to an annual dividend yield of 3–4% suggests a high probability of total long-term returns exceeding the market average. Investors should use the rebalancing calculator to adjust the appropriate allocation between dividend stocks and growth stocks, and use the asset allocation calculator to build a dividend income strategy aligned with retirement goals.
Performance Analysis of Dividend Aristocrat ETFs
SCHD (Schwab US Dividend Equity ETF) holds 104 high-dividend, high-quality stocks with an extremely low expense ratio of 0.06% and a dividend yield of 3.42%. Top holdings include Broadcom at 4.8%, Merck at 4.2%, Amgen at 3.9%, Home Depot at 3.7%, and PepsiCo at 3.5%. Sector allocation is financials 23%, healthcare 18%, industrials 15%, consumer staples 12%, and technology 10%. Over the past three years, SCHD delivered an annualized return of 12.3%, slightly ahead of the S&P 500's 11.8%. Its year-to-date return for 2024 stands at +14.2%, in line with the broader market. During the October correction, SCHD declined only 2.8% versus the S&P 500's 5.2%, generating 2.4 percentage points of excess return. In terms of dividend characteristics, the average annual dividend growth rate of 8.2% outpaces inflation; quarterly dividend payments provide stable cash flow; and the average payout ratio of 45% supports long-term sustainability. VIG (Vanguard Dividend Appreciation ETF) holds 289 dividend growth stocks with an expense ratio of 0.06% and a dividend yield of 1.68%. Top holdings include Microsoft at 4.3%, Apple at 4.1%, Broadcom at 3.8%, JPMorgan at 3.2%, and UnitedHealth at 2.9%. Sector allocation is technology 24%, financials 20%, healthcare 15%, industrials 12%, and consumer staples 10%. Over the past three years, VIG posted an annualized return of 13.1%, higher than SCHD. Its 2024 year-to-date return is +16.8%, with its higher technology weighting providing an advantage in rising markets. During the October correction, VIG fell 3.1%, offering slightly less downside protection than SCHD but still outperforming the broader market. On the dividend side, VIG's average annual dividend growth rate of 9.5% is higher, though its yield of 1.68% is lower; capital appreciation rather than dividend income is the primary return driver.
Advantages of Dividend Investing and Retirement Portfolios
The core advantages of dividend investing include stable cash flow, with predictable dividends collected each quarter that can be used for living expenses or reinvestment; dividend income as a supplement to retirement pension; and the psychological stability of receiving dividends even during market downturns. Regarding the dividend reinvestment effect, reinvesting dividends maximizes the power of compounding: reinvesting SCHD's 3.4% dividend over 20 years grows principal by 191%. Automatic dividend reinvestment allows shares to be repurchased without commission fees, and dividend growth increases purchasing power — an 8% annual dividend growth rate doubles the dividend in approximately 10 years (2.2x over 10 years). For downside protection, SCHD focuses on high-quality companies with strong financial stability, a low beta of 0.85 reduces volatility by 15% relative to the market, and a P/E of 18x represents an attractive discount compared to the S&P 500's 22x. As an example retirement portfolio, investors in their 60s approaching retirement might hold SCHD 30%, VIG 20%, AGG 30%, TLT 10%, and cash/gold 10%, prioritizing stability with a dividend yield of 4% or more and minimizing volatility. Retirees in their 70s might hold SCHD 25%, VYM 15%, AGG 40%, short-term bonds 5%, and cash 15%, targeting a 4.5% dividend yield to cover living expenses while prioritizing capital preservation. For rebalancing strategy, quarterly reviews maintain target weights within ±5%; dividend reinvestment provides an automatic buying-on-dips effect; and the rebalancing calculator precisely determines when and how much to adjust.
SCHD vs. VIG Comparison and Selection Criteria
These two ETFs share a dividend growth strategy but differ in approach. In terms of dividend yield, SCHD at 3.42% suits retirees who need immediate cash flow, while VIG at 1.68% is better suited for long-term investors who benefit from its higher dividend growth rate. On a $1 million investment, SCHD generates approximately $34,200 in annual dividends versus VIG's $16,800 — roughly double. In terms of dividend growth, SCHD's 8.2% annual growth increases the dividend by 2.2x over 10 years, while VIG's 9.5% growth results in a 2.5x increase, meaning VIG's dividend can potentially surpass SCHD's over the long run. For sector exposure, SCHD is centered on traditional industries with financials at 23% and healthcare at 18%, offering lower volatility and greater defensive characteristics; VIG has higher exposure to technology at 24% and financials at 20%, providing an advantage in bull markets with somewhat higher volatility. On performance, in the 2023 bull market when the S&P returned +26%, SCHD returned +18% while VIG returned +22%; in the 2022 bear market when the S&P fell 18%, SCHD fell 8% while VIG fell 12%, highlighting SCHD's superior defensive characteristics. Over the long term, both ETFs have delivered similar 15-year annualized returns — SCHD at 12.1% and VIG at 12.8%. For investor type selection, retirees prioritizing cash flow might use SCHD 70% + VYM 30% to secure a 3.8% dividend yield with stability as the top priority; middle-aged investors seeking balance might use SCHD 40% + VIG 40% + QQQ 20% for a balanced dividend-and-growth allocation, using the rebalancing calculator for quarterly adjustments; and younger growth-oriented investors might use VIG 30% + QQQ 40% + SCHD 15% + AGG 15% to maximize compounding through dividend reinvestment and pursue long-term wealth accumulation. Regarding tax efficiency, SCHD's higher dividend component leads to a greater dividend income tax burden of 15.4%, so holding SCHD in an ISA or pension account is recommended; VIG is more capital-gain-oriented, making it possible to utilize the 2.5 million KRW capital gains tax exemption in a regular brokerage account.
Rebalancing Strategy for Dividend and Growth Stocks
The appropriate allocation between dividend stocks and growth stocks should be adjusted based on market conditions and investment objectives. By market phase: during a bull market with strong upward momentum, growth stocks QQQ and TQQQ can be increased to 60%, dividend stocks SCHD and VIG reduced to 25%, and bonds AGG minimized to 15% to maximize returns, with monthly reviews via the rebalancing calculator. During a sideways or mildly declining correction, a balanced allocation of growth stocks 40%, dividend stocks 35%, and bonds 25% increases defensive assets, reduces volatility, and maintains weights through quarterly rebalancing. In a clear bear market downtrend, dividend stocks SCHD and VIG can be increased to 50%, bonds AGG and TLT increased to 35%, growth stocks reduced to 15%, and a cash position held to capture buying opportunities. By age group: investors in their 20s–30s in the wealth accumulation phase can hold growth stocks 60%, dividend stocks 25%, and bonds 15%, reinvesting all dividends to maximize long-term compounding and actively accepting volatility. Investors in their 40s–50s in the stabilization phase can use growth stocks 40%, dividend stocks 40%, and bonds 20%, pursuing a balanced dividend-and-growth approach with semi-annual rebalancing via the calculator to strengthen risk management. Investors aged 60 and older in retirement can hold dividend stocks 50%, bonds 35%, growth stocks 10%, and cash 5%, prioritizing stable cash flow, funding living expenses with dividend income, and targeting capital preservation. For rebalancing triggers: if the allocation deviates more than ±7% from target, an adjustment is made — for example, if dividend stocks rise from 40% to 47%, 7 percentage points are sold; if growth stocks outperform dividend stocks by more than +20%, some profits are taken and rotated into dividend stocks; and when VIX is at or above 25, dividend stock allocation is increased by 10 percentage points, while when VIX is at or below 15, the growth stock allocation is restored.
Long-Term Investment Simulation for Dividend Growth Stocks
Let us simulate the long-term compounding effect of dividend growth stocks. Based on an initial investment of 100 million KRW: in the SCHD 100% scenario, the initial dividend yield of 3.4% generates 3.4 million KRW in annual dividends; with an 8% dividend growth rate, the annual dividend grows to 7.34 million KRW after 10 years; with annual price appreciation of 9%, the principal grows to 237 million KRW after 10 years; and with dividend reinvestment, total assets reach 285 million KRW — a 185% increase from the original principal. After 20 years, annual dividends grow to 24.3 million KRW and total assets reach 742 million KRW, a 642% increase from principal. In the VIG 100% scenario, the initial dividend yield of 1.7% generates 1.7 million KRW annually; with a 9.5% dividend growth rate, annual dividends grow to 4.2 million KRW after 10 years; with annual price appreciation of 11%, the principal grows to 284 million KRW after 10 years; and with dividend reinvestment, total assets reach 321 million KRW — a 221% increase from principal. After 20 years, annual dividends grow to 16.7 million KRW and total assets reach 985 million KRW, an 885% increase. The blended strategy of SCHD 50% + VIG 50% generates initial annual dividends of 2.55 million KRW at a blended yield of 2.55%; with an average dividend growth rate of 8.75%, annual dividends grow to 5.77 million KRW after 10 years; with an average price appreciation of 10%, the principal grows to 259 million KRW after 10 years; and total assets reach 302 million KRW — a 202% increase. After 20 years, annual dividends grow to 20.5 million KRW and total assets reach 858 million KRW, a 758% increase. For a retirement income simulation: if an investor retires at age 65 with 500 million KRW allocated as SCHD 60% + VIG 40%, first-year dividend income is approximately 14.4 million KRW annually or 1.2 million KRW per month; with 8.5% dividend growth, income grows to 31.2 million KRW annually — 2.6 million KRW per month — after 10 years; the high likelihood of capital preservation means the principal grows to approximately 580 million KRW by age 75; and living expenses can be fully covered by dividends alone without drawing down the principal, enabling a stable retirement. Use the asset allocation calculator to back-calculate the initial capital needed for a target retirement income, use the rebalancing calculator to optimize the dividend reinvestment ratio, and make active use of ISAs and pension accounts for tax efficiency.
Conclusion
Dividend aristocrat ETFs provide stable cash flow and defensive characteristics amid market volatility. SCHD, with its higher dividend yield, is well suited for investors who need immediate income, while VIG, with its superior dividend growth rate, is better for those seeking long-term wealth accumulation. Use the rebalancing calculator to fine-tune the appropriate allocation between dividend stocks and growth stocks, and use the asset allocation calculator to build a dividend income strategy aligned with your retirement goals.
Related Portfolios
#[KO] 리밸런싱 계산기#[KO] 자산배분 계산기#SCHD#Dividend Growth#[KO] 방어 투자
Related Articles
Have any questions?